Perry’s NYSF First Look: Brooklyn’s Grandma Pizza

Brooklyns Grandma Pizza

A new pizza truck arrived on the scene recently called Brooklyn’s Grandma Pizza. You don’t see a lot of Grandma-style pizza places around, but Valducci’s and Jiannetto’s are two other local practitioners.

They had 5 or 6 different toppings to choose from on the menu, and we went for 2 complete opposites: a broccoli slice for $4 and a meat-lovers slice for $4.50.

Not having an Italian grandmother, we don’t know if there’s an “official” Grandma-style. To us it’s characterized by square slices like Sicilian, but unlike Sicilian, the crust is thin. Sauce and cheese are also usually sparser than on the traditional round NY-style pie.

(credit: Perry R.)
(credit: Perry R.)

The slices we received had some mozzarella and globs of tomato sauce. This pizza was not gooey and stringy like a regular, triangular slice. This was more like a baked slice of pizza.

Despite it not looking like there were a lot of toppings, we did get cheese, sauce and broccoli in nearly every bite.

The meat-lovers had sausage, pepperoni, and a little bit of ground meatball. The pepperoni had more flavor than the sausage, which was on the boring side.

The tomato sauce was decent, with a strong tomato flavor, some oregano, and a thick consistency more akin to tomato paste than tomato sauce.

The crust was nice and crispy on the outside, and softer away from the edge. The slices were about the length and width of a Sicilian slice, but not the height.

You can find Brooklyn’s Grandma Pizza on twitter here, on facebook here, and their website is here.

(credit: Perry R.)
(credit: Perry R.)



  1. Actually there IS an “official” grandma pie. It’s characterized by “fresh” ingredients, in other words fresh mozz (not the prepackaged stuff), fresh basil (no dried), fresh garlic, and whole tomatoes (think more a can of stewed tomatoes smooshed onto the crust rather than sauce). Also befor ethe dough is put on the pan…it’s oiled…so the dough kind of fries.

    It’s kind of like Pizza Margherita with an attitude…this story has it pretty good:

    Having had a Sicilian Grandmother I can attest to this…


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.