UPDATE TO ORIGINAL POST: After spending the afternoon with Today’s Lunch last Friday, I’m not going to add Sara Halal Food Cart to the NYSF directory or map. The roof of my mouth had a film on it for most of the day, and I wasn’t crazy about the way the food sat in my stomach throughout the afternoon.

New York Street Food is about finding the BESTstreet food in New York. While the lunch from Sara Halal Food Cart was ok, it was not of the quality where I would recommend it over other food carts. Lunch needs to be a cut above what is found on most street corners for it to be recommended by New York Street Food.

Sara menu

ORIGINAL POST: For Today’s Lunch, it was 20 degrees, so I went to the closest street food cart to my office, on the SW corner of West 57th St and 8th Ave, in front of the Hearst Building. I’ve noticed this cart lately, called Sara Halal Food, because it’s a relative newcomer to the neighborhood and smelled great when I walked by several times over the past few weeks. There were usually a few people standing around waiting for food, so today I decided to give it a whirl.

I don’t usually go for the chopped chicken at these carts because I’ve had not-so-great experiences with it, so I asked for the gyro platter because I saw the spit of gyro meat in the corner of the cart. When they were cutting the meat off the spit, I noticed whole pieces of boneless chicken on the grill with an orange-ish rub on it, and he was chopping the chicken up right there. When I saw that, I changed my order to the chicken and gyro platter combo.

chicken on grill

The chicken was a combination of white and dark meat, but since it was chopped right in front of me, it was recognizable as chicken and pretty tasty. The white sauce was mayonnaise-y instead of yogurt-y (if those are even words) and nothing special, but the hot sauce was actually hot. That’s not always the case at these carts.

Gyro-chicken platter

The lamb gyro was the expected gyro meat, and with the hot sauce, was enjoyable, too. I preferred the chicken, but both were decent.

The rice was ok. Not overcooked, but a little bland. Scooped up with meat and sauce, it was fine, but by itself it was fairly tasteless. The salad was fresh lettuce and a little tomato, with the white sauce pulling double-duty as the salad dressing, which was not a great idea. I’d prefer a basic Italian dressing (really any other dressing) to the white sauce on my salad.

To summarize Today’s Lunch, the chicken, lamb gyro and hot sauce were good, the rice was ok, and I would pass on the white sauce next time. However, a chicken and lamb gyro combo for only $5 is not a bad deal. I want to try either a chicken or falafel sandwich next time before passing judgement.

If anyone else had lunch at Sara Halal Food Cart on 57th St and 8th Ave, please give us your thoughts in the Comments.


  1. When on vacation in New York City, my family and I thoroughly enjoyed this plate of lamb over rise as being the best meal in New York! The line of customers was almost always very long. We once counted 38 customers waiitng for their turn at purchasing this great meal. Can\\\’t wait to return to New York just so we can go eat this great food again. We also enjoyed the chicked plate.

  2. I buy food from this cart on 57th and 8th every week.
    This has got to be the best cart food you can get in NYC. Don’t get me wrong, I have tried food from many other “Halal Food Carts” in NYC and the food is consistently good. I find though, that the best tasting food is prepared by the gentlemen from the middle east. They are also very courteous and very generous with portions. This is the best deal you can get in NYC. Don’t pass this up. Get soem feed today. This is a very NYC cultural must!

  3. Lamb gyro with red sauce and extra white sauce. The truth. I tried this place for the first time the afternoon after dropping $400 on dinner at a fancy restaurant, and this gyro had more soul, more nuance, and more flavor than anything at said fancy resto. I go here 3-4 times a week now.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.