Dining in Times Square: Do It in Style

dining in times square
Times Square. Photo by Artem Zhukov on Unsplash.com

Head over to Times Square, or even just outside this iconic neighborhood, to find some of the most scrumptious food in the city. Whether you are in the mood for comfort food, fine dining, or maybe something in between, you can find it in or near Times Square. 

If you are craving seafood, Asian, Mexican, Italian, or a good burger, you can find the perfect restaurant in Times Square. Check out the 10 restaurants listed below for enticing dishes and mouth-watering menus!

Whether you try one of these restaurants at each day’s end, you’ll want to explore this exciting destination hands-free. Drop your bags at a luggage storage locker before you venture through the streets looking for the perfect place to dine. 

Top Places For Dining in Times Square:

1. Crab House Seafood 

This is not your typical seafood buffet. At this all-you-can-eat buffet, the food is made fresh to order rather than sitting out in steam trays or under heat lamps. The Cajun-style dishes are made with the freshest seafood in New York. 

Crab House Seafood is a popular place and you will definitely not leave here hungry! You don’t have to be a seafood lover to enjoy this incredible buffet; there are plenty of tempting beef dishes and savory noodle and rice dishes. You can even take home your leftovers for a small fee. 

2. Los Tacos No. 1

Serving delicious Mexican and Central American cuisine, Los Tacos No. 1 has an extensive menu bursting with spicy Latin flavors. There are also gluten-free and vegetarian options to be had for those with dietary restrictions.

The pulled pork taco is a must-try! It is unlike any taco you have ever tasted. The quesadillas are also fantastic if you are not in the mood for tacos. Relax at this trendy restaurant with friends over a tantalizing lunch or dinner and a few cold drinks. 

3. Le Bernardin

This Michelin-starred restaurant is the perfect place to come when searching for a high-end meal. Le Bernardin does accept walk-ins but you may want to make a reservation a few weeks in advance as it is a popular restaurant in Times Square. 

Order the Dover sole or put your taste buds in the chef’s hands and order the four or eight-course tasting menu. The truffle tagliatelle pasta is simply divine. Their menu does boast vegetarian and gluten-free options. Save room for the special dessert of the night! 

4. Tony’s Di Napoli – Midtown

When in the mood for Italian in Times Square, head over to Tony’s Di Napoli and enjoy classic, traditional southern Neapolitan cooking. The food is served on family-style platters that can easily serve two to three people. 

Order the mussels appetizer platter while you wait for your main course to arrive. The shrimp scampi over linguini is a great choice for your entrée or the tortellini alfredo or lasagna. The menu does have vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options. 

5. Margon

This is one of my favorite places for dining in Times Square. Serving traditional Cuban and Caribbean fare, Margon’s menu offers fresh ingredients and tasty dishes made to order. The Cubano Sandwich is one of their specialties and is served with rice and beans, bursting with traditional Latin flavor. 

Other specialties include pepper steak, Palomilla steak, and fried kingfish. The wonderful chicken sandwich served with plantains, rice, and beans is juicy and very filling. They also have a great selection of soups. Vegetarian options are also available on the menu. 

6. Toasties

This gourmet delicatessen is family-owned and operated and has been creating fantastic dishes in New York’s Times Square for quite a while now. Toasties is the place to go when in the mood for fresh salads and amazing sandwiches. 

If you do not see the vegan, vegetarian, or gluten-free options on the menu, just ask and the staff will help you find what you are looking for. There are much enjoyable bread and bagel options for your sandwich. The chicken teriyaki or Italian heroes are delicious.

7. Burger & Lobster

Where else can you find a big, juicy burger and the freshest lobster in New York City other than Burger & Lobster? Their menu focuses on making prime burgers and elevating wild Atlantic lobster to a whole other dimension.

Burger & Lobster’s lobster roll is an absolute must-try! Even if you are not a big fan of seafood you will find it delightful. The burgers are made to order and served on a brioche bun. Save plenty of room for the chocolate mousse, their specialty dessert.

8. The Mean Fiddler

Come experience an authentic family-operated Irish pub and restaurant at The Mean Fiddler. The menu boasts popular dishes such as Fish & Chips, Fiddler Burger, Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls, and Shepherd’s Pie. 

Sit back with friends and enjoy a Fiddler Mule, a specialty cocktail, or the Espresso Martini. Save plenty of room for the dessert of the day and a cup of coffee to top off your meal. You will want to make reservations as this appealing eatery is a very trendy spot for locals. 

9. The Capital Grille

Located in the Time-Life Building, the Capital Grille is an American steakhouse serving fantastic dry-aged steaks and fresh seafood dishes. There are even gluten-free and vegetarian options on their extensive menu

With over 7,000 bottles of wine available, the staff will help you choose the perfect wine for your meal. Start your meal with crab cakes, raw oysters, or steak tartare. The New York Strip is cooked to order and absolutely heavenly. 

10. Bibble & Sip

While not technically a restaurant, Bibble & Sip should not be missed when you are visiting Times Square. This delectable bakery serves gourmet coffees and pastries. Many of their treats on the menu have a French or Asian twist. 

All the baked goods are made at Bibble & Sip, including the marshmallows on the hot chocolate and the granola in the yogurt! If you are not in the mood for a coffee or espresso, try one of the specialty lattes such as jasmine and lavender. 

You will have a hard time choosing which restaurant you want to try first when dining in Times Square. Each one is unique and offers a fantastic menu that will leave you wanting to try more and more.

These top restaurants in Times Square are just a sampling of the food scene that has begun to explode in this neighborhood. Whether you are searching for casual dining, upscale fine dining, or even a bakery, you will find it near here!