If you’re on a righteous quest for the best burger in Buffalo, look no further than a little joint in Blasdell called Off The Wall Sandwich Co.—home to a monstrous creation known as The Billz Mafia. This isn’t just a burger. It’s an edible tribute to Buffalo’s wildest tailgates, wrapped in a bun and daring you to finish it without breaking a sweat. In this post, as part of our NY food reviews, I’ll delve into my burger experience…
I stumbled in expecting a solid sandwich. What I got was a full-blown flavor riot, stacked higher than Josh Allen’s passing yards and twice as dangerous.
This is not your casual Tuesday-night burger. This is the kind of burger that grabs you by the tastebuds and shouts, “Welcome to Buffalo, baby!”
Watch this video by Buffalo AF to get a glimpse of the place:
What’s in The Billz Mafia Burger Anyway?
Let me paint you a picture: a juicy and rich ground steak patty is stacked with cheddar cheese, thick-cut bacon, and a fried chicken finger drenched in tangy Buffalo sauce. As if that wasn’t already reckless enough, they throw on blue cheese crumbles and a heaping scoop of Buffalo chicken wing dip.
Yes, wing dip. On a burger. And somehow…it works.
It’s as if someone took the top five items at a Bills tailgate and said, “Let’s make this one sandwich, and let’s make it count.” The result? A burger that tastes like civic pride and a minor heart attack—and I’m here for it.
What Does It Taste Like?
Imagine a Bills fan doing a touchdown dive through a buffet table—but make it delicious.
The patty is deeply savory, the blue cheese gives you that creamy tang, and the chicken finger adds that crisp-meets-chew texture you didn’t know a burger needed. And then there’s that wing dip—hot, cheesy, and unapologetically messy. I won’t lie: I needed a stack of napkins and maybe a moment of reflection after the last bite.
Get the full-size ($20) if you’re feeling brave or the Jr. version ($13.50) if you’re still emotionally recovering from last night’s game.
Is Off The Wall Sandwich Co. Worth the Trip?
If you’re anywhere near Buffalo, make the trip. The shop itself is unassuming, but don’t let that fool you. The team behind the counter knows they’re dealing in edible adrenaline. You don’t come here for dainty plating or quiet ambiance—you come for stacked, unapologetically ridiculous food that actually delivers on flavor.
While The Billz Mafia is the showstopper, the rest of the menu is no slouch either. But let’s be honest—you came for the burger that eats like a love letter to the 716.
Watch this reel by Jimmy Scott Jr. to get another glimpse:
What Should You Know Before You Go?
- Current Location: Off The Wall Sandwich Co., 4068 N Buffalo St, Orchard Park, NY 14127
- New Location (Opening Mid-2025): Off The Wall Sandwich Co., 4154 McKinley Pkwy, Suite 400, Blasdell, NY
- Plan ahead: There might be a line during peak lunch hours, especially on game day weekends.
- Bring wet wipes—you’ll thank me later.
- Share it… or don’t. This is technically a one-person burger, but only if you hate your arteries.
People Also Ask
How messy is it?
Let’s just say if your shirt stays clean, you did it wrong.
Is it kid-friendly?
Absolutely, if your kid eats like a lineman.
Does it live up to the name?
It’s bold, chaotic, a little wild, and beloved by locals. If that’s not Bills Mafia energy, I don’t know what is.
Anthony is a passionate food enthusiast living in the bustling food scene of New York City. With an insatiable curiosity for culinary exploration, he loves exploring the city’s diverse eateries, seeking out unique flavors and sharing his gastronomic adventures with fellow food lovers.
